All of our past blogs on the subject of stop-arm cameras have been about catching motorists that have passed stopped school buses. But recently we found an article on motorists complaining about receiving traffic tickets for just that.
The Courthouse News Service has reported that Dallas, TX drivers have filed a class action lawsuit against the city and its schools, claiming they are illegally issuing traffic tickets for passing stopped school buses, using photos taken by cameras on the bus’ stop arms. The plaintiffs claimed the Texas Transportation Code grants no authority to local authorities to pass ordinances that conflict with it.
“No bill, law, statute or constitutional amendment has ever been passed that would authorize any local government in Texas to enact camera-enforced school bus stop arm ordinances which conflict with statutorily established ‘Rules of the Road’ in Texas,” the 53-page complaint stated.
A motorist was fined $300 after a bench trial in Carrollton Municipal Court for passing a stopped school bus. He said the photographic enforcement and administrative adjudication of school bus stop-arm violations was never authorized by the state: That bills in the legislature that would have allowed it failed in the past four legislative sessions. A non binding opinion by the Texas Attorney General’s office in 2002 concluded cities could not use automated enforcement equipment to impose a civil penalty for running a school bus.
“The Attorney General noted Texas cities were prohibited from doing this, because making the running of a school bus camera a civil penalty would conflict with state law that makes the running of a school bus camera a crime (a misdemeanor) under Transportation Code,” the complaint stated.
Either way, passing a stopped school bus should have consequences for the motorist.